Sketch ready:
Final drawing:

M 51 (Whirlpool galaxy)

M 51 (Whirlpool galaxy)

Drawing data

Object(s):
M 51 CVn GX
NGC 5195 CVn GX
Date(s) of observation:
2014.03.28/29. Ágasvár
2014.03.29/30. Ágasvár
Place(s) of observation:
Ágasvár
Telescope(s) used:
16" f/4.4 Newtonian (MCSE Dobson)
Enlargement(s) used:
176x (10mm Delos)
Field size:
25'
Author / Observer:
Peter Kiss

Description

M 51 drawing inverted into positive.
M 51 drawing inverted into positive.

M 51 barely needs introduction. This interacting pair of galaxies is undoubtedly one of the deep-sky highlights of the northern hemisphere. The system looks good in a small scope as well but it truly shines in a larger telescope. I didn't feel this kind of joy during deep-sky drawing for two years prior to drawing M 51. Last time it was in June 2012 in Namibia when I drew M 83. Here I could get lost in the tiny details of the spiral arms for many hours again. These details could be listed like the square parts of the arms of the main component, the bright spots in these arms which have shapes and some of them are also inhomogenoius. A thin bright thread is visible in one of the arms. Or I could mention the inhomogenious core of NGC 5195 with the bright and dark spots, dark lanes and bright bridges... But I think the drawing speaks for itself. It is interesting that I think that the view in the 16" Dobsonian was on the edge. I am sure that using a little bigger telescope under maybe a little better sky it would be possible to see much more. There are the dust lanes in the spiral arms. I could see only something of these in a short section of one of the arms. And there are some background galaxies behind the Whirlpool galaxy. I spent at least 1.5 hours to try to see IC 4278, the brightness of which is given at 15.4m. But I didn't see it. Note that there are more 16.0m stars in the drawing.

M 51 drawing from 2000 (Ágasvár) using a 4
M 51 drawing from 2000 (Ágasvár) using a 4" Newtonian. Peter Kiss
M 51 drawing from 2014 (Ágasvár) using a 16
MM 51 drawing from 2014 (Ágasvár) using a 16" Newtonian. Peter Kiss

I have already drawn M 51. It was in 2000 at Ágasvár just like in 2014 but with a 4" Newtonian. It was a very good night as well, a good observation.

Comparison with the photograph

M 51 drawing using a 16" telescope (inverted into positive).
M 51 drawing using a 16" telescope (inverted into positive). Peter Kiss
M 51 photograph by Jon Christensen using a 12.5" RC telescope.
M 51 photograph by Jon Christensen using a 12.5" RC telescope. Credit: Jon Christensen, Source: christensenastroimages.com

The photo above, courtesy of Jon Christensen was made using a 12.5" RC telescope. Jon Christensen's original photograph has been cropped and my inverted drawing rotated to show a similar area of the sky.

Of course the photograph is much more spectacular. Nevertheless the live view was pretty good as well. The 16" Dobsonian showed the Whirlpool galaxy in magnificient detail. I can imagine that the dust lanes in the spiral arms can be seen with a little bigger telescope. IC 4278, the background galaxy mentioned above can be seen a little to the left and a lot under the center of the photo. It is worth comparing the stars as well.

The sketch I made under the sky by the telescope. I used this to process the drawing.
The sketch I made under the sky by the telescope. I used this to process the drawing.

Latest drawings